At a glance
| Field | Detail |
|---|---|
| What | Decide whether to add creative assets, replace existing assets, or investigate reporting before a refresh. |
| Who it matters to | App advertisers reviewing creative performance in Google Ads App campaigns. |
| Where | Google Ads asset reports, with AppsFlyer or Adjust reporting used on its stated measurement basis. |
| When it applies | During an existing campaign's creative review, after checking asset ratings, format coverage, and reporting detail. |
| Action | Review available asset capacity and measurement scope before removing a creative. |
Google App campaign assets need a review that connects the rating to the creative's role and the report behind it. Our suggested approach is to establish what the rating measures, check whether the campaign needs more variety, and then decide whether replacement is justified.
Read the rating in its reporting context
Google's single-ad-group asset report rates Low, Good, and Best relative to assets of the same type within the campaign. Learning means more data is needed. Compare headlines with headlines and videos with videos.
Google bases these insights on the last 14 days and recommends matching that period when comparing metrics. The rating column always shows the current rating, regardless of the selected date range. Treat a historical date selection accordingly. See Google's asset reporting documentation.
Our suggested check is to record the report level and asset type alongside the rating before assigning a production task. This makes the reason for a refresh clearer than a list of Low labels alone.
Decide whether the gap is variety or replacement
Google's creative guidance recommends adding assets similar to those rated Best when capacity remains. Once the permitted asset capacity is reached, it recommends replacing Low assets gradually to limit performance fluctuations. The same guidance supports grouping assets around specific app features or messages.
Google's methodical campaign guidance adds an important placement qualification: a Low portrait video may still serve placements that a landscape video does not suit. It also warns that limited creative diversity can skew the analysis.
Our interpretation is to review the replacement's message and orientation together. If removing an asset also removes useful format coverage, the production brief should explain how the incoming asset addresses that gap.
| Decision or approach | Source-backed capability | Limitation | Suggested check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wait on a Learning asset | Google identifies assets needing more ranking data. | Learning does not establish a Low rating. | Check the status before treating the asset as a replacement candidate. |
| Add creative variants | Google recommends adding assets resembling Best assets when capacity remains. | Asset capacity constrains additions. | Review available capacity and missing messages or orientations. |
| Replace a Low asset | Google recommends gradual replacement when capacity is full. | A Low portrait video may still suit particular placements. | Review format coverage before removal. |
| Use AppsFlyer creative analysis | AppsFlyer models performance allocation across assets in multi-asset creatives. | Allocated outcomes have a modeling basis. | Identify the metric's source before judging a variant. |
| Use Adjust's Creative dimension | Adjust reports network type and subtype for App campaigns. | This dimension does not identify an individual creative file. | Check the dimension definition before joining it to asset data. |
Keep asset analysis and campaign totals aligned
Google's enhanced asset reporting documentation provides asset identifiers, orientation, type, state, and policy status, along with performance metrics. These fields can help distinguish the asset being evaluated from its reporting or approval context.
The documentation also warns that asset metrics can count multiple components of an ad impression. It directs advertisers to campaign totals for accurate overall performance and spend tracking. Asset reports may show served cost rather than billed cost and may exclude costs from automatically created assets.
Our suggested use is to diagnose creative choices at asset level while keeping the campaign's overall spend assessment at campaign level.
Establish what the measurement tool actually reports
The AppsFlyer Creative Optimization guide explains that multi-asset Google App campaign creatives use modeled allocation across assets. It also distinguishes Google partner metrics based on the asset view from AppsFlyer data aligned to the ad group view. Those reporting bases do not align directly. Differences can also arise from attribution logic, time zones, and data freshness.
Adjust's Google Ads reporting documentation maps the Creative dimension for App campaigns to network type and subtype. It also says ad group and creative dimensions are unavailable for probabilistic attribution through Integrated Conversion Measurement; deterministic attribution retains details where available.
Our interpretation is to treat an unavailable dimension or modeled allocation as a limit on the comparison. Establish that limit before interpreting a report difference as evidence that a creative should be removed.
What to review
- Check the asset type, report level, current rating, and comparison period.
- Compare unused asset capacity with the need for gradual replacement.
- Review whether removing a creative would reduce orientation or message coverage.
- Check whether outcomes are partner-reported, attributed, or allocated through modeling.
- Keep campaign spend totals distinct from asset participation metrics.
- Record missing dimensions before drawing a conclusion about an individual file.
Use a creative test plan to document the proposed change. Align the report definitions through a measurement data review when the evidence comes from different tools.



